There are two ways to keep moisture off the guns in a safe: warm the air so it cannot condense, or pull the water out of it. An electric rod does the first. A rechargeable gun safe dehumidifier does the second. They are not interchangeable, and which one you want depends mostly on where the safe sits.
How an electric rod works
A rod is a low-wattage heating element. It raises the air inside the safe a few degrees above the room, which keeps the air moving and stops water from condensing on cold steel. It does not remove any moisture. The humidity in the safe is still whatever the basement is; the rod just keeps it from settling on your guns.
Upsides: silent, nothing to maintain, runs for years. Downsides: you need to drill a hole in the safe for the cord (most safes have a knockout for it), you need an outlet close by, and when the power goes out it stops. Sizing is by cubic feet, so a big safe needs a longer rod or two of them.
How a rechargeable dehumidifier works
A rechargeable unit is a block of desiccant, usually a silica-type material, that absorbs water vapour from the air until it is saturated. Then you dry it out with heat and use it again. Some plug into a wall outlet to recharge. The Silent Dry Hypercube goes in the microwave, which is faster and does not tie up an outlet overnight.
Upsides: no cord, no hole, works in a cabinet, a hard case or a vehicle, and it keeps working through a power outage. It actually lowers the humidity rather than hiding it. Downsides: you have to recharge it, and if you forget, it stops working. The Hypercube has a hygrometer on the face so you can see when it is time, which fixes most of that.
Head to head
- Install: rod needs a hole and an outlet. Rechargeable sits on the shelf.
- Running cost: rod draws a little power all year. Rechargeable costs a minute in the microwave every few weeks.
- Cottage, garage, off-grid: rod is out. Rechargeable is the only option.
- Power outage: rod stops. Rechargeable does not care.
- More than one safe or case: a rod per safe, each with its own outlet. Rechargeable units move wherever you need them.
- If you forget about it: rod keeps going. Rechargeable stops when it is full. Read the hygrometer.
- Very wet basement: a rod alone will not get you under 50 percent. Rechargeable will, but you will recharge it often. Running both is the answer here.
Which one to buy
Safe in a heated, finished room with an outlet behind it, and you never want to think about it again: get a rod.
Safe in a basement, garage, cottage or anywhere without a convenient outlet, or you have cases and cabinets as well as a safe: get a rechargeable. This is most people in Canada.
Basement that runs 65 percent or more all summer: both. The rod stops condensation, the desiccant brings the number down.
Sizing a rechargeable gun safe dehumidifier
Bigger safe, bigger block. Small for a cabinet or a handful of long guns. Medium for a typical 20 to 30 gun safe. Large for a big safe or a damp basement where you want margin between recharges. For a pistol case or ammo can, the Invisible Stone is the same material in a block that fits in the foam cutout.
Whichever you pick, put a VCI emitter with the guns you care about most. A VaporTack in the chamber protects the steel directly, so the day you forget to recharge is not the day the rust starts.
All of it is in the Silent Dry section, and our Hypercube guide has the specs for each size.