Hunting, Information & Education

Beretta vs Benelli: Which Shotgun Should You Buy? A300, A400, M2 and SBE3

Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 semi-auto shotgun with black synthetic stock

Beretta vs Benelli is one of the oldest arguments at any duck camp, and the funny thing is that it is the same family. Beretta has owned Benelli since 1983. But the two build their semi-autos in completely different ways. Beretta uses gas, Benelli uses inertia, and that one difference decides how each gun kicks, how often you clean it, and what it weighs. Here is how they compare, model against model, with what each costs at CANFIREARM right now.

Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 inertia semi-auto, the Benelli side of the Beretta vs Benelli debate

Beretta vs Benelli: the short version

Beretta Benelli
Semi-auto system Gas-operated Inertia-driven
Felt recoil Softer Sharper
Cleaning More often Less often
Weight A little heavier A little lighter
Light target loads Cycles them well Can be picky
Best at Clays, high-volume shooting Hunting in bad weather
In stock from $1,400.00 $745.00 (pump), $1,925.00 (semi-auto)

Gas vs inertia, in plain English

A gas gun bleeds a little of the gas from each shot to push the action back and load the next shell. That spreads the recoil out, so it feels softer, and it cycles light loads reliably. The price is carbon in the action, so it needs cleaning more often, and the extra parts add weight.

An inertia gun uses the recoil itself. The gun moves back, a spring in the bolt stores that energy, and the bolt cycles. No gas enters the action, so it stays clean for a long time and has fewer parts to freeze or foul in a wet, cold blind. The trade is that you feel more of the kick, and very light loads may not cycle it.

Neither is better. They are better at different things.

Beretta A300 Ultima vs Benelli M2 Field

The entry pair. The Beretta A300 Ultima 12 gauge 28 inch is $1,400.00, a synthetic gas gun that is soft on the shoulder and the cheapest Beretta semi-auto we sell. The Benelli M2 Field 12 gauge 28 inch is $1,925.00, a light inertia gun that stays clean all season. It also comes in 20 gauge at $1,925.00 and Realtree Max-7 camo at $2,150.00.

Pick the A300 if you shoot clays as much as you hunt, or recoil bothers you. Pick the M2 if you hunt in rain and sleet and hate cleaning, or you want a 20 gauge.

Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus vs Benelli Super Black Eagle 3

The waterfowl pair, and the most common Beretta vs Benelli decision at this price. Both are 3.5 inch magnum guns built for ducks and geese.

The Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus in Realtree Max-7 is $2,694.99, and we also have it in Mossy Oak Bottomland at $2,694.99, Shadow Grass at $2,760.00 and Optifade Marsh at $2,760.00. The A400 uses Beretta’s fast-cycling Blink gas system and is the softer shooting of the two with heavy steel loads.

The Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 is $2,710.00, or Realtree Max-7 at $2,940.00, and there is a 20 gauge SBE3 BE.S.T. at $2,970.00. It has the inertia action and the ComforTech 3 stock, and it is the one to take when the marsh is freezing over.

Beretta’s AX800 Suprema is on pre-order at $2,774.00. Our AX800 review covers it. For more waterfowl guns at every price, see our best duck hunting shotgun guide.

Pumps and tactical: Benelli

Benelli has the pumps. The SuperNova Tactical is $745.00, the SuperNova 28 inch in Max-7 is $935.00, and the SuperNova with a rifled slug barrel is $1,295.00. At the top end, the Benelli M4 Super 90 is $2,810.00, the civilian version of the shotgun the US Marines adopted as the M1014, and the M4 with a telescoping stock is $3,050.00. Unlike Benelli’s hunting guns, the M4 is gas-operated.

Over-unders: Beretta, easily

If you want an over-under, this is not close. Beretta’s 687 Silver Pigeon III ($4,140.00) and 694 Sporting ($6,509.99) are what you see at clay clubs, and the DT11 is the gun many top shooters use. Benelli makes over-unders too, but we do not stock them. Our best over under shotgun guide has every one we carry.

Beretta vs Benelli: which to buy

  • Mostly clays, some hunting: Beretta A300 Ultima, $1,400.00.
  • Mostly hunting, hate cleaning: Benelli M2 Field, $1,925.00.
  • Ducks and geese, softest recoil: Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus, $2,694.99.
  • Ducks and geese, worst weather: Benelli Super Black Eagle 3, $2,710.00.
  • Upland 20 gauge: Benelli M2 Field 20, $1,925.00.
  • A pump that will outlast you: Benelli SuperNova, from $745.00.
  • Clays over-under: Beretta 694, from $6,509.99.

Not ready to spend Italian money? Our guide to Turkish shotguns covers inertia and gas guns under $800. Beretta’s own specs are on the Beretta site.

Prices current as of September 2026. Check each product page for live stock. A non-restricted PAL is required.